Retrofit Revisit by 10 Design + CIBSE, Housing design, Marion Baeli, Julie Godefroy, Innovate UK

Retrofit Revisit Report – 10 Design + CIBSE

12 July 2024

New research “Retrofit Revisit” reveals crucial lessons for future retrofits

Findings after ten years reveal that retrofitted residences perform outstandingly against non-retrofitted UK housing stock and for the long term

Marion Baeli Julie Godefroy:

photo courtesy of architects office

Retrofit Revisit Report by 10 Design + CIBSE

Today, co-authors Marion Baeli, Principal – Sustainability Transformation at 10 Design (part of Egis’ Architecture Line) and Julie Godefroy, Head of Net Zero Policy at CIBSE, announced the launch of Retrofit Revisit published via CIBSE.

Supported by Innovate UK, part of UK Research and Innovation and Historic England as well as in-kind contributions from project partners including Studio PDP, Retrofit Revisit investigates how ten housing projects of varying archetypes and locations are performing 10 years after their original retrofit. The findings reveal that despite small fluctuations in performance over a decade, the retrofitted residences outperform the non-retrofitted housing stock overall. Residents’ feedback on their ten years of occupancy in these retrofits has been positive, with increased comfort, especially during the colder months and with reduced energy bills.

Marion Baeli, Principal – Sustainability Transformation at 10 Design said:

“In publishing “Retrofit Revisit,” our goal is to boost confidence in the lasting benefits of retrofitting while also emphasizing the insights gained from building performance evaluations and identifying areas needing further research to ensure the reliability and longevity of building fabric and operations. Through this collaborative research effort, we aim to support the nationwide retrofitting of existing homes across the UK.”

The projects build on pioneering case studies from ten years ago, which were considered ‘deep retrofit’ (aiming towards 80% CO₂ emission reduction) and exemplar at the time, including some from the Retrofit for the Future programme. Six of the Retrofit Revisit case studies were covered in Residential Retrofit: Twenty Case Studies, published by RIBA in 2013 and completed while Marion Baeli was at Studio PDP.

All ten projects underwent a rigorous Building Performance Evaluation (BPE) to assess various aspects such as fabric, energy efficiency, indoor environment, airtightness, and user feedback. These evaluations employed a blend of standard and non-intrusive techniques to ensure a thorough analysis, learn about the value of innovative evaluation techniques, as well as the performance of the buildings over time.

Julie Godefroy, Head of Net Zero Policy at CIBSE, said:
“Retrofit Revisit shows that, when done well, retrofit provides huge energy savings as well as comfortable homes. I hope this will encourage more studies to gather lessons on more retrofit typologies and larger samples, but that it will also give confidence to industry and policy makers to implement retrofit at scale”.

The evaluations, completed by a team comprised of well-known experts in the retrofit sphere, emphasise the crucial role of good design and detailing, and regular maintenance in optimising the performance of buildings, regardless of their retrofit status. Neglected components such as gutters and ventilation filters can lead to problems like water ingress and inadequate air quality. Easy-to-maintain retrofitted homes are more likely to stand the test of time, whereas those with complex maintenance requirements will not.

The research demonstrates the reliability of deep retrofit measures, when implemented with attention to detail at the design stage and on-site. The homes provide high levels of comfort while maintaining low energy demands over a long period of time, instilling confidence in the industry that retrofitting initiatives are a worthwhile investment.

Additionally, the research sought to evaluate the practicality and resilience of various testing methodologies and techniques, with the goal of making BPE more routine and widespread. The projects show the high potential for more routine BPE, combining well-established tests such as airtightness testing with more innovative testing for fabric thermal performance, fabric degradation and ambient mould.

The UK Climate Change Committee (CCC) recognises that retrofits are a large part of the net-zero trajectory of the UK. Achieving the nation’s carbon reduction targets necessitates a significant increase in the efficiency of existing housing stock. Retrofit Revisit’s aim, therefore, is to inspire confidence and encourage the rollout of retrofit measures on a national scale.

Mat Colmer, Senior Innovation Lead – Construction & Net Zero Heat at Innovate UK, part of UK Research and Innovation, said:

“It’s been over 10 years since Innovate UK invested £25million in the Retrofit for the Future programme. It is important that we learn from such programmes and how they fair over time. Retrofit Revisit does exactly this, providing designers and decision-makers, as well as home occupants, the confidence that when a job is done well it delivers on performance and market certainty for the retrofit industry.”

Hannah Reynolds, Architect Historic Building Retrofit at Historic England, shared:

“BPE and maintenance are key to the successful retrofit of traditional buildings. The project demonstrates the need for testing of moisture and fungal levels as a vital part of evaluation, to understand the suitability and longevity of deep retrofit proposals. The research also highlights the critical role of maintaining building fabric and services in order to achieve long term positive outcomes.”

The Retrofit Revisit is available to download here: https://www.cibse.org/knowledge-research/knowledge-portal/retrofit-revisit-2024

Background

Full list of team members & steering group members below.

Authors:

Marion Baeli, 10 Design
Julie Godefroy, CIBSE

Sponsors and Funders:

Caroline Cattini-Dow, Historic England
Hannah Reynolds, Historic England
Mat Colmer, Innovate UK, part of UK Research and Innovation

Laura Morgan Forster, Innovate UK, part of UK Research and Innovation
10 Design
Studio PDP

Steering Group:

Sarah Price, Passivhaus Trust
Morwenna Slade

Kate Simpson, Imperial College London
David Glew, Leeds Beckett University
David Allinson, Loughborough University

Lynne Sullivan, LSA Studio
Sally Godber, Warm
Zachary Gill, SOAP Retrofit

Peter Rickaby, UCL
Rokia Raslan, UCL

Evaluators:

Paul Jennings, Aldas
Gabriel Anstree, Bere Architects
Justin Bere, Bere Architects

Luke Smith, Build Test Solutions
Helen Grimshaw, Carbon Co-op
Lilija Oblecova, ECD Architects

Lizzy Westmacott, ECD Architects
Loreana Padron, ECD Architects
Andy Macintosh, Feilden Clegg Bradley Studios

Joe-Jack Williams, Feilden Clegg Bradley Studios
Marianne Heaslip, People Powered Retrofit
Mike Roe, Warm

Robert Prewett, Prewett Bizley Architects
Konstantinos Megagiannis, QODA Consulting
Tim Wilcockson, QODA Consulting

Toby Cambray, UCL
Spyros Efthymiopoulos, UCL
Valentina Marincioni, UCL

10 Design

10 Design, part of Egis’ Architecture Line, is a global architecture and master planning practice.

A dynamic team of 400 architects and designers are strategically located across three regional headquarters in London, Hong Kong, and San Francisco, and six additional studios in pivotal global markets – Dubai, Edinburgh, Miami, Dallas, Shenzhen, and Singapore.

10 Design operates at various scales, navigating the design of individual buildings to the intricate planning of entire cities, prioritising environmental, economic and social responsibility in its multicultural projects. The firm’s portfolio encompasses a diverse range of works, from grand mixed-use developments to dynamic retail, office, residential, hospitality, transport, educational, cultural, and civic projects. 10 Design’s hallmark innovative and multidisciplinary approach has produced work that has received over 340 international awards including recognised as one of the top 50 most significant architectural practices in the world on the WA100 list. For more information, visit www.10design.co.

About CIBSE

The leading authority on building services engineering and a pioneer in responding to the threat of climate change, CIBSE exists to advance global best practice in the profession. Through harnessing the expertise of our members, CIBSE represents the profession as a trusted voice to provide advice and guidance to Government on matters relating to construction, engineering, and sustainability.

For over 125 years, CIBSE has supported a community of over 20,000 professionals worldwide in their pursuit of excellence in building performance, sustainability and safety to influence the well-being of individuals and communities of today and of future generations. CIBSE members continue to create the most environmentally friendly systems in major projects across the globe. Find out more about CIBSE via www.cibse.org

Historic England

We are Historic England: the public body that helps people care for, enjoy and celebrate England’s spectacular historic environment, from beaches and battlefields to parks and pie shops. We protect, champion and save the places that define who we are and where we’ve come from as a nation. We care passionately about the stories they tell, the ideas they represent and the people who live, work and play among them. Working with communities and specialists we share our passion, knowledge and skills to inspire interest, care and conservation, so everyone can keep enjoying and looking after the history that surrounds us all.

Innovate UK, UK Research and Innovation

Innovate UK is the UK’s national innovation agency. We support business-led innovation in all sectors, technologies and UK regions. We help businesses grow through the development and commercialisation of new products, processes, and services, supported by an outstanding innovation ecosystem that is agile, inclusive, and easy to navigate.

www.ukri.org/councils/innovate-uk/

Mews House Deep Retrofit London images / information received 120724