Children in community participatory planning process guide, Role research advice

Children in Community Participatory Planning Process

12 July 2024

Pusan National University Researchers Explore the Role of Children in Community Participatory Planning Process

Researchers explore child participation in urban planning, emphasizing active involvement in decision-making for safer environments

Role of Children in Community Participatory Planning Process

Child-friendly cities prioritize safe environments, healthcare, education, green spaces, and children’s participation in decision-making processes. However, children are consulted only for ideas and often excluded from public spaces. A recent study by researchers from Korea tackled pedestrian safety around school zones using child-inclusive participatory planning. Their approach included field work, community mapping, and collaborative solution development. Children effectively identified safety risks, shaping a robust safety plan with potential to significantly enhance community safety.

The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child defined child-friendly cities as those that prioritize children’s access to safe environments, healthcare, education, green spaces, and the right to participate in decision-making processes about their surroundings. Despite the importance, children are often overlooked in urban planning, consulted mainly for ideas rather than being actively involved in implementation of the ideas. Involving children fosters community interaction and enhances their understanding of how physical environments impact well-being. However, despite these benefits, children often face exclusion from public spaces due to limited capacity for independent movement and physical activity.

Recently, researchers from Pusan National University, led by Professor Donghyun Kim, Associate Professor at the Department of Urban Planning and Engineering, aimed to address this gap. Their study focused on conducting a participatory planning process with children and apply the findings to improving walking safety in a school zone in Busan. This study was published online on 17 June 2024 in the journal of Planning Theory & Practice. Sharing the purpose of their study Dr. Kim explains, “Our study aims to construct a community participatory planning process involving children and apply this planning process to a case related to the road safety problem of the school zone.”

The study used a three-step participatory community planning process, that was designed based on interactions between the planner (comprised of six undergraduate and five graduate students from the Department of Urban Planning and Engineering at Pusan National University) and participants (89 children of grades 5 and 6). Initially, both planner and participant groups conducted separate field work and community mapping exercises. Despite initial challenges, the children effectively identified various walking safety risks, such as illegal parking zones, intersections, unsafe crosswalks near their school which were mapped and discussed using online tools like KakaoTalk Open Chat. All the identified spaces were congested with heavy vehicle movement in unpredictable directions and speeds.

In the second step, the planner group reviewed their findings and developed multiple solutions for the identified problems. Children rank preferences among the proposed solutions based on safety, impact, convenience, and cost, through an online survey. Sites for selected solutions including pedestrian-first streets, raised crosswalks, painted sidewalks, and bollards to prevent illegal parking, were then marked using Google Jamboard.

The final step involved creating a comprehensive community walking safety plan. Combining the survey results, the planners proposed installing pedestrian-first streets, painting sidewalks, adding bollards, marking crosswalks, and installing parking entrance alarms in and around the school area. This plan was then presented to the local government and local council and proposed as a policy.

The study highlighted how children successfully took part in participatory planning, despite challenges posed by restrictions due to COVID-19 and varying participant interest. Community maps, virtual tools, and shared understanding acted as effective tools in effectively utilizing children’s participation.

Dr. Kim pointed out, “Our study shows that children can be the main actors in planning for community issues. The communicative planning process proposed in our study can be applied to bridge the gap between planners and residents in solving problems of various themes such as pedestrian safety problem for children, community renewal, and community climate change adaptation.”

To conclude, this innovative urban planning approach empowers children, enabling their unique perspectives to contribute to the creation of safer, and more inclusive environments.

Reference

Title of original paper: Children as Key Actors in Participatory Planning: Co-Working Experience of Community Planning for Walking Safety Around Bongrae Elementary School in South Korea

Journal: Planning Theory & Practice

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/14649357.2024.2363790

About the institute

Pusan National University, located in Busan, South Korea, was founded in 1946 and is now the No. 1 national university of South Korea in research and educational competency. The multi-campus university also has other smaller campuses in Yangsan, Miryang, and Ami. The university prides itself on the principles of truth, freedom, and service, and has approximately 30,000 students, 1200 professors, and 750 faculty members. The university is composed of 14 colleges (schools) and one independent division, with 103 departments in all.

Website: https://www.pusan.ac.kr/eng/Main.do

About the author

Professor Donghyun Kim is an Associate Professor at the Department of Urban Planning and Engineering, Pusan National University. His research interests include participatory planning, collaborative governance, and community resilience. Before coming to Pusan National University, he worked at Korea Environment Institute. Dr. Kim has published several articles about community participatory planning and urban resilience. Prof. Donghyun received his PhD in Urban Planning and Engineering from Yonsei University in 2012.

Website: https://sites.google.com/view/rdpl-pnu
ORCID id: 0000-0003-3711-5103

Image Information:

Image title: Community participatory planning process involving children aiming to improve road safety in s school zone

Image caption: Researchers explore the impact of children participating in urban planning process such as increasing walking safety around an elementary school in Busan, Korea

Image credit: Professor Donghyun Kim from Pusan National University, Korea

License type: Original Content

Usage restrictions: Cannot be reused without permission

Comments on this guide to Children in community participatory planning process article are welcome.